Indiana University

National Sports Journalism Center

Sports Media News

New York Times, Yale Daily News endure criticism for coverage of quarterback scandal

Kelly McBride writes for Poynter, “As the story of Yale University quarterback Patrick Witt (and his Rhodes scholarship that wasn’t) got more convoluted last week, both The New York Times and the Yale Daily News came under significant criticism — The Times, for running with a story that had too many holes, the Yale paper for holding a story they should have reported.

The critics are right. Both papers missed the journalistic mark on this one. The Times chose the wrong frame to tell the story. The Daily News let protocol prevent its journalists from acting as watchdogs. Because of these journalistic failures, the larger systemic issues faded into the background of our national conversation.

In case you missed it, here’s a quick recap: Last fall, the Rhodes Scholarship Selection Committee chose Witt as a finalist, leaving him with a tough choice: attend the day-long interview or play in the legendary Yale-Harvard game.

Witt withdrew from the scholarship, played in the game and garnered a lot of attention in the sports media,fueled by the Yale Public Relations Department, for putting the needs of his team in front of his own.”

Click here to read more from McBride.

Tools: | permalink

No Responses to “New York Times, Yale Daily News endure criticism for coverage of quarterback scandal”


    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    Our Voices

    Guest Blogs

    more Guest Blogs »

    The Buzz

    Jul 22, 2014Tony Dungy clarifies Michael Sam statement

    In a widespread press release, Dungy provides context to his controversial remarks regarding St. Louis Ram Michael Sam. [ESPN]

    Jul 22, 2014SEC Network poised for most successful sports cable channel launch

    The SEC Network’s August launch will make it the fifth largest and fifth most lucrative sports channel in cable television [FOX Sports].

    Jul 21, 2014Buffalo Bills could be sold for $1 billion

    NFL sources are saying the Buffalo Bills could be sold by the Wilson family for at least $1.1 billion [CBS Sports].

    more of The Buzz »